The golden era of muscle cars in the 1960s and 70s brought us some of the most legendary designs and boldest color choices in automotive history. Dodge had its “High Impact” colors like Plum Crazy and Hemi Orange, Ford offered wild shades like Grabber Green, and GM brands added stripes and graphics that turned cars into rolling billboards for horsepower. But for every iconic color, there were some factory shades that seemed to completely miss the point. These paints dulled the aggression of muscle cars, clashed with their styling, or just looked more at home on a family sedan. Today collectors either laugh at them or pay attention only because of their rarity. Here are twelve of the worst factory colors ever sprayed onto classic muscle cars.
Ford Mustang in Lime Gold
Ford introduced Lime Gold in the late 1960s, and while it was meant to look bold and modern, it landed in a strange middle ground between metallic olive and washed out gold. On a Mustang fastback or convertible it looked more tired than aggressive, especially compared to brighter colors like Candyapple Red or Acapulco Blue. Many of these cars sat longer on dealer lots as buyers gravitated toward flashier shades. Ironically, today Lime Gold Mustangs are rare enough that collectors sometimes pay a premium just for the oddity, but few would call it a flattering look.
Dodge Charger in Butterscotch Tan
The Charger, especially in its second generation form from 1968 to 1970, is one of the most intimidating muscle car shapes ever created. Unfortunately Dodge offered it in Butterscotch Tan, a flat beige like tone that stripped the car of its menace. On a Charger R/T with a 440 Magnum or even the legendary 426 Hemi, the paint looked more like it belonged on a station wagon than a drag strip dominator. While Mopar fans now appreciate almost any color for rarity, Butterscotch Tan Chargers remain some of the least photographed and least sought after at shows.
Chevrolet Camaro in Beige
The Camaro debuted in 1967 to fight the Mustang, and Chevy marketed it as a car with attitude. Offering it in beige seemed like a cruel joke. While performance options like the Z/28 and SS gave the Camaro serious credibility, the beige exterior made the car look anonymous. In fact, many beige cars of the era were ordered by rental fleets, which only added to the bland image. Today most collectors repaint them in bolder colors, meaning surviving factory beige Camaros are rare but still rarely celebrated.
Pontiac GTO in Verdoro Green
Pontiac launched Verdoro Green as its signature color for the 1968 GTO, thinking it would look sophisticated and unique. In certain light it had depth, but in most cases it came across as dull olive or swamp green. For a car nicknamed “The Goat” and marketed as the original muscle machine, the color just felt out of character. Despite this, Verdoro Green became surprisingly common because Pontiac pushed it heavily in ads. Collectors today sometimes prize it for being period correct, but enthusiasts still joke that it looks better on military vehicles than muscle cars.
Plymouth Road Runner in Soft Yellow
The Plymouth Road Runner was designed as a no nonsense muscle car with cartoon graphics and a brash personality. That made its Soft Yellow option particularly uninspired. While Dodge and Plymouth offered outrageous High Impact colors like Vitamin C Orange and In Violet, this pale yellow looked like a refrigerator shade from the 1950s. On a stripped down 383 Road Runner coupe it just looked cheap, and even with stripes or decals it never quite lived up to the car’s rowdy image. Today these cars do stand out at shows, but usually because collectors wonder why anyone ordered them in that color.
AMC Javelin in Brown
AMC always struggled to stand out against the Detroit Big Three, and while the Javelin was a sharp looking car, painting it in flat brown robbed it of presence. Many 1971 to 1974 Javelins left the factory in earthy tones, but brown was the worst offender, making the car look like a commuter sedan instead of a pony car competitor. The irony is that AMC also offered some wild oranges and blues, so choosing brown was like dressing a sprinter in a business suit. Collectors today tend to repaint these cars, meaning surviving factory brown examples are rare, but not for the right reasons.
Oldsmobile 442 in Silver Beige
The Olds 442 was a sleeper muscle car with serious punch, especially in W30 trim with the 455 V8. Yet Oldsmobile saddled it with Silver Beige, a champagne like tone that looked more at home on a Cutlass Supreme luxury coupe. Instead of emphasizing its wide stance and hood scoops, Silver Beige washed out the car’s lines. At the time, some older buyers probably appreciated the subdued look, but enthusiasts saw it as a mismatch. Today it remains one of the least popular collectible 442 colors.
Dodge Challenger in Light Blue Metallic
The Dodge Challenger arrived in 1970 with a palette of wild Mopar hues, but Light Blue Metallic was the softest option. While not as outright offensive as beige, it simply drained the Challenger of personality. On a high performance R/T with a Shaker hood, the color clashed with the aggressive lines. Buyers who wanted attention went for Plum Crazy or Top Banana Yellow, leaving the pale blue cars looking timid by comparison. Collectors today acknowledge the rarity but admit it does not capture the Challenger’s spirit.
Mercury Cougar in Pastel Blue
Mr.choppers, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
Mercury tried to position the Cougar as a more refined pony car, but Pastel Blue tipped too far into soft luxury. On the XR7 with its sporty interior and performance engines, the gentle hue made the car seem more timid than powerful. While darker shades like Competition Orange or Bright Blue Metallic fit its muscle luxury vibe, Pastel Blue gave the Cougar an almost economy car appearance. Surviving examples today are curiosities at shows, but most restorers prefer bolder paint.
Chevrolet Chevelle Malibu in Sea Mist Green
The Chevelle Malibu SS was one of the true kings of the muscle car wars, with big block engines that ruled the drag strip. Unfortunately, when painted in Sea Mist Green, it lost nearly all of its visual punch. The light, watery tone did nothing to emphasize the car’s muscular stance. On lesser Malibu trims it looked appropriate, but on an SS396 or SS454, it was almost embarrassing. Collectors often overlook these examples unless they are exceptionally original, preferring Chevelles in darker or brighter colors.
Dodge Super Bee in Cream
The Dodge Super Bee was a brash muscle car known for bold stripes, cartoon decals, and rowdy engines. Offering it in Cream felt completely out of character. While it did make the graphics stand out more, the soft color tone made the car look timid and even a little dated. For a car designed to be cheap, loud fun, Cream was the least fitting choice on the chart. Today these cars are very rare but remain among the least desirable at auction.
Plymouth Barracuda in Brown Metallic
The Plymouth Barracuda, especially in high performance Cuda form, was a showstopper. With aggressive styling and powerful engines, it was a true street brawler. Brown Metallic, however, muted its lines and gave it the aura of a mid size sedan. While Mopar was offering outrageous colors like Sassy Grass Green and Panther Pink, buyers who chose Brown Metallic seemed determined to disappear. Today, Brown Metallic Cudas are some of the rarest survivors, but their collectibility comes more from scarcity than beauty.
25 Facts About Car Loans That Most Drivers Don’t Realize
Car loans are one of the most common ways people fund car purchases. Like any other kind of loan, car loans can have certain features that can be regarded as an advantage or a disadvantage to the borrower. Understanding all essential facts about car loans and how they work to ensure that you get the best deal for your financial situation is essential. Here are 25 shocking facts about car loans that most drivers don’t realize:
25 Facts About Car Loans That Most Drivers Don’t Realize
