Some vehicles may seem like a great deal upfront, especially on the used market, but Canadians often find out the hard way that low purchase prices can hide shockingly high repair costs. Whether it is due to unreliable engineering, rare parts, or complicated electronics, these vehicles can quickly turn into bottomless money pits. Here are 22 vehicles that will cost you more in repairs than the purchase price:
BMW 7 Series (2002–2008)
The early-2000s BMW 7 Series is a tempting buy for Canadians eyeing luxury on a budget. But what seems like a $6,000 steal quickly becomes a $12,000 lesson. Known for fragile electronics, air suspension failures, and iDrive issues, repairs are constant and expensive. Even minor fixes require specialized tools and labor, and the V8 engine is prone to oil leaks and timing chain problems. Many owners report spending more on repairs than the car cost, especially in cold climates where sensors and modules tend to fail more frequently.
Land Rover Range Rover (2012–2017)
Range Rovers may scream status, but Canadian owners often find themselves screaming at repair shops. These vehicles are notorious for experiencing electronic gremlins, suspension problems, and coolant leaks; an air suspension failure alone can cost over $5,000 to repair. Add in harsh winters that accelerate wear and tear, and you’ve got a luxury SUV that will cost extra every month. Buying one used might save you at first. Still, most owners end up paying double the original price in long-term upkeep. For a brand built on ruggedness, the Range Rover has proven unusually fragile on Canadian roads.
Audi A8 (2010–2016)
Audi’s flagship sedan dazzles with its interior tech and Quattro performance, but it’s a trap for the unwary Canadian buyer. The A8’s complexity makes even routine maintenance a high-stakes affair, as timing chain replacements, transmission issues, and electrical bugs are all common and highly costly. Many used examples can be found for under $15,000, but it is not unusual for owners to incur $ 20,000 or more in repairs over a few years. Add the cost of premium fuel, pricey brakes, and suspension repairs, and the A8 quickly becomes a luxury liability rather than a deal.
Chrysler Sebring (2001–2010)
Once a staple of rental fleets, the Chrysler Sebring is now better known for being an unreliable headache. From failing transmissions to electrical issues and engine ticking, repairs on a Sebring often outpace its rock-bottom resale value. A $2,000 used Sebring might seem like a cheap commuter, until you’re paying more to fix the engine, alternator, and cooling system than you paid for the entire vehicle. It is no surprise that this car is frequently seen in scrapyards across Canada.
Mercedes-Benz ML350 (2006–2011)
This midsize luxury SUV seemed like a winner for Canadian families, until the repair bills started arriving. Common issues include transmission failure, fuel system faults, and persistent electrical problems, while suspension and brake repairs can cost thousands, and parts availability has become a growing concern. Many buyers purchase these for under $10,000, unaware that total ownership costs often double that amount. In winter, sensor malfunctions and battery drain issues become even more pronounced.
Mini Cooper S (2007–2014)
Mini’s compact charm hides a maintenance nightmare, particularly for turbocharged “S” models. Canadians often find themselves incurring expenses for timing chain tensioners, oil leaks, and transmission failures, not to mention labor-intensive engine bay access that increases shop time. While these quirky cars can be had cheaply, repair costs frequently exceed the purchase price over a few winters. The cold climate is harsh on the already sensitive electronics and plastic components.
Volkswagen Touareg (2004–2010)
Volkswagen’s early SUV was designed to compete with high-end brands, but it also came with high-end repair bills. Canadians who purchase used Touaregs often encounter chronic issues, including air suspension failure, transmission breakdowns, and electrical malfunctions. Even minor parts are expensive and hard to source, especially for V10 TDI and V8 models. The cost of repairs often doubles the price of the used vehicle. With its poor fuel economy and expensive tire replacements, the Touareg continues to cost owners long after the initial thrill wears off.
Dodge Journey (2009–2020)
A perennial favorite on the used lot, the Dodge Journey attracts buyers with its low price, but leaves many regretting the decision. The Journey suffers from HVAC failures, brake system problems, and transmission issues that accumulate quickly. As many Canadian owners report, repair costs often exceed the vehicle’s value within a few years. Its outdated electronics and flimsy interior materials don’t hold up well in winter. While it might seem like a budget-friendly family hauler, the Journey’s long-term cost of ownership makes it one of the most deceptive bargains in the Canadian market.
Jaguar XF (2009–2015)
The Jaguar XF seduces used buyers with its sleek design and low price, but it hides some of the most expensive repair bills in the luxury segment. From electrical issues and water ingress to failing timing chains and unreliable infotainment systems, the XF bleeds money. At the same time, Canadian winters only exacerbate the situation, causing sensors and modules to fail prematurely. Jaguar parts are costly and often take weeks to arrive. Add in pricey labor and premium gas, and it is easy to see how a $12,000 used XF can rack up $15,000 in repairs within just a few winters.
Chevrolet Aveo (2004–2011)
The Aveo is often one of the cheapest used cars on Canadian lots, but even at $1,500, it can be a bad investment. Owners frequently face recurring issues with timing belts, head gaskets, and transmissions. Many parts are discontinued or hard to find, especially for earlier models, while labor costs can easily eclipse the vehicle’s value after just a few repairs. It might seem like an ideal first car or winter beater, but the Aveo proves that cheap upfront doesn’t mean cheap in the long run.
Ford Focus (2012–2016)
While the Ford Focus was once a top choice for Canadians seeking compact efficiency, the 2012–2016 models are now infamous for their issues with the dual-clutch transmission. Repeated shuddering, slipping, and outright failures have led to class-action lawsuits, leaving owners with repair bills that exceed the vehicle’s resale value. Replacement transmissions can cost $4,000 or more, often exceeding what the car’s worth on the used market.
Cadillac CTS (2008–2014)
The Cadillac CTS promised performance and refinement, but many Canadian owners got a lesson in costly maintenance instead. Timing chain problems, electrical failures, and AWD drivetrain issues are all too common. The direct-injection engines tend to develop carbon buildup, and repairs can cost thousands. Used CTS models are easy to find for under $10,000, but the cost of ownership quickly balloons. Adding to the pain, replacement parts are often dealer-only and slow to arrive. In cold climates, the electronics can behave erratically, making this once-premium sedan more of a liability than a luxury.
Saab 9-3 (2003–2011)
Quirky and turbocharged, the Saab 9-3 still has a cult following in Canada, but owning one is a costly adventure. Since Saab went bankrupt in 2011, parts have been scarce, and repairs require specialized knowledge, which translates to big bills at independent shops or, worse, repairs that take months. Common issues include failing ignition coils, power steering leaks, and problematic electrical systems. Even if you score one for under $4,000, it’s not unusual to spend double that keeping it roadworthy.
Hyundai Veracruz (2007–2012)
The Hyundai Veracruz is a forgotten midsize SUV that initially seemed like a bargain, until owners began encountering electrical issues and catastrophic engine failures. The alternator often fails prematurely, draining the battery, and the 3.8L V6 is known to suffer from timing chain and gasket issues. Repair costs frequently exceed the resale value of the SUV, which often sells for under $6,000. The cold weather appears to accelerate the failures, with many Canadian owners reporting warning lights and stalling during the winter.
Subaru Tribeca (2006–2014)
Subaru’s first foray into the three-row SUV market was short-lived and for good reason. The Tribeca suffers from head gasket failures, overheating issues, and expensive suspension repairs. While Subaru’s AWD is great in Canadian winters, the Tribeca’s 3.6L engine is expensive to service and prone to leaks. A used model might go for $5,000-$8,000, but repairs can easily double that in just a few seasons. Its cramped interior and dated infotainment don’t help its case either, and although some Subarus are cult favorites, the Tribeca is better known for burning holes in wallets.
Acura RL (2005–2012)
The Acura RL tried to compete with BMW and Mercedes, but it quietly faded from the spotlight, and not without reason. This full-size sedan is known for transmission failures, malfunctioning SH-AWD systems, and complex electronics that are expensive to fix. Used RLs are tempting at under $10,000, but the cost of ownership quickly erases any initial savings. Canadians have reported navigation screen failures, high labor costs for repairs, and winter-related issues, including frozen sensors and dead batteries.
Saturn Outlook (2007–2010)
The Saturn Outlook shares a platform with other GM crossovers, but it is the least reliable among them. Common issues include water leaks, failing power steering systems, and transmission problems that can be more costly than the car’s value. Since Saturn was discontinued in 2010, parts availability has become a challenge for Canadian owners. Even if you find a clean Outlook for under $5,000, repair bills can quickly soar into five figures. Add in poor winter durability and a dated interior, and it’s no surprise that many of these are now rusting in back lots.
Volvo XC90 (2003–2014)
The first-gen Volvo XC90 promised safety and Scandinavian luxury, but it has since earned a reputation for mechanical and electrical headaches. Transmission failures, all-wheel-drive system problems, and suspension issues are just the beginning. Canadian winters are particularly harsh on wiring and electronics, often causing sensor malfunctions and warning light overload. Used prices are often under $7,000, but long-term costs can easily triple that amount. Additionally, Volvo repair shops are scarce in many provinces, and parts are particularly pricey.
Jeep Commander (2006–2010)
The Jeep Commander had the rugged looks and off-road promise, but ultimately proved to be one of the brand’s most problematic models. Known for electrical system failures, transmission issues, and poor fuel economy, the Commander quickly transformed from a family SUV to a money pit. Canadian owners in colder climates frequently report battery drain problems and failing sensors. Finding a clean one might only cost $6,000, but keeping it running could require double that in repairs. Add in a notoriously cramped third row and a sluggish V6, and it is easy to see why the Commander never caught on.
Infiniti QX56 (2004–2010)
Infiniti’s big SUV came with a big V8, and even bigger repair bills. Canadians who buy used QX56s often encounter brake booster problems, failing suspension components, and engine issues that cost thousands. Rust is also a significant issue in snowy provinces, especially around the rear frame and brake lines. Parts are expensive, and fuel economy is abysmally low, making it a wallet-buster on multiple fronts. It might tow a boat or handle snow well, but the QX56 has proven to be a textbook example of a vehicle whose total repair cost often exceeds its purchase price.
Peugeot 505 (1980s Imports)
Though rare, older Peugeot 505s occasionally surface in collector or niche markets in Canada. But for the few who dare to own one, repair costs are sky-high, particularly because parts are nearly impossible to find, and very few mechanics are equipped or willing to work on them. Even basic maintenance can require importing components from overseas, making a $3,000 car a $10,000 burden. If you’re driving in a Canadian winter, you must remember that the heating systems and electrical reliability are notoriously poor.
Tesla Model S (Early Builds: 2012–2015)
While Tesla has revolutionized the EV industry, early Model S vehicles have become known for expensive out-of-warranty repairs. Issues with the MCU touchscreen, door handles, air suspension, and battery degradation plague these models. In Canada, the cold affects range and battery performance more severely than many anticipated. If you picked one up for $25,000 used, don’t be surprised if repair and replacement costs push your total ownership well past $40,000. Tesla service centers are still limited across parts of the country, making even minor fixes a logistical and financial hassle.
21 Products Canadians Should Stockpile Before Tariffs Hit
If trade tensions escalate between Canada and the U.S., everyday essentials can suddenly disappear or skyrocket in price. Products like pantry basics and tech must-haves that depend on are deeply tied to cross-border supply chains and are likely to face various kinds of disruptions
21 Products Canadians Should Stockpile Before Tariffs Hit
