Every generation of cars has its duds. Some models don’t just depreciate they collapse in value, inspire endless complaints and eventually appear on classifieds with desperate “must sell” prices. In Canada, where winter weather, long highway distances and fierce resale markets expose flaws quickly, a few cars have developed reputations so poor that owners just want them gone. Here are ten models that often show up with dealers and private sellers practically begging buyers to take them off their hands.
Fiat 500 (2007–2019)
Canadians liked the idea of a fun, retro city car until they lived with one. The first-generation Fiat 500 has one of the most frequent service histories in small car segments: transmission complaints, electrical quirks, heater failures and more. Winter exposure only highlighted its shortcomings. Today they flood classifieds with low asking prices because owners just want reliability back in their lives.
Mitsubishi Mirage
The Mirage promises low cost of entry and excellent fuel economy, but acceleration, interior quality and NVH (noise, vibration, harshness) levels leave much to be desired. Many buyers trade them in for more engaging used cars or simply sell when discovery drives reveal how compromised the small size feels on Canadian highways and winter roads.
Ford EcoSport
It never had a strong fanbase in Canada. The EcoSport’s tall ride height and odd rear door design don’t offset a choppy ride, loud drivetrain and uninspired power delivery. Owners often trade these SUVs sooner rather than later, leaving a surplus of cheap examples on used markets.
Nissan Juke
Stylish on the outside but awkward everywhere else. The Juke’s polarising styling helped its early sales, but compromised interior space, firm ride and quirky handling made long term ownership feel like a daily challenge. Many Canadian owners list them for sale after a couple of years, often at steep discounts.
Smart Fortwo
The Fortwo’s tiny footprint solves parking problems in urban cores, yet most of Canada lives outside dense cities. Its rough ride, slow acceleration and awkward transmission behavior made it a short stint for many owners. Cheap prices on classifieds reflect how quickly buyers move on to more practical alternatives.
Chevrolet Sonic
The Sonic promised fun hatchback energy, but reliability reports and build quality questions undercut enthusiasm. Ride quality, transmission complaints and mediocre resale value made these easy to dump when buyers realized how many better options existed in the compact segment.
Mini Countryman (Early R60)
Early Countryman models deliver quirky style, but they also delivered expensive repairs. Transmission issues, electrical gremlins and high maintenance costs chased many Canadian owners into the resale market prematurely. You’ll find clean examples, but most have been cycled quickly by hesitant owners.
Jeep Renegade (Early Years)
Fun looking and rugged in ads, but early Renegades struggled with reliability and transmission complaints. Harsh ride, frequent service visits and below average winter traction on base trims made owners question their decisions before the first winter ended. Many list them hoping someone else will take the headache.
Volkswagen Tiguan (First Generation)
Despite strong brand appeal, the first Tiguan proved costly to maintain. High parts and repair bills combined with frequent electrical issues made it a car owners dumped as soon as they could afford to. Canadian buyers often cite out of pocket costs rather than driving dynamics as the main reason for selling.
Dodge Dart (2013–2016)
The Dart arrived with a lot of hype but fell short in execution. Its Italian-sourced engine and transmission pairing felt underpowered and unreliable to many drivers. Interior space was tight and the platform felt dated compared to rivals. Consequently, it ended up in classifieds with low prices and owners eager to walk away.
Why These Cars End Up Unwanted
Most cars on this list share common patterns: disappointing reliability, high maintenance costs, weak performance or poor winter behaviour. In Canada, where extended winters push drivetrains and electronics hard, cars that struggle in cold weather or require frequent service quickly become “cars to get rid of.” When buyers move on, they can create a flood of supply that suppresses resale prices further, making the cars even harder to sell a vicious cycle.
Thinking of buying one of the “lemons?” Do extra research, get a thorough inspection and factor in cost of ownership, especially winter readiness. And if you already own one and wonder how to get rid of it, timing your sale ahead of winter often yields better results.
25 Facts About Car Loans That Most Drivers Don’t Realize
Car loans are one of the most common ways people fund car purchases. Like any other kind of loan, car loans can have certain features that can be regarded as an advantage or a disadvantage to the borrower. Understanding all essential facts about car loans and how they work to ensure that you get the best deal for your financial situation is essential. Here are 25 shocking facts about car loans that most drivers don’t realize:
25 Facts About Car Loans That Most Drivers Don’t Realize
