SUVs dominate today’s roads, but most people who buy them do not actually need them. Once designed as rugged vehicles for off road travel, they have morphed into oversized family haulers marketed as lifestyle choices rather than practical tools. While SUVs make sense for a small percentage of buyers who tow heavy loads or live in rural areas with poor roads, the majority of drivers would be better served by sedans, wagons, or hatchbacks. With higher costs across the board and limited real world advantages, here are twelve reasons why modern SUVs are pointless for most people, backed up with real world comparisons and figures.
They Rarely Go Off Road
The vast majority of SUV buyers never leave pavement. Surveys show that over 85 percent of SUVs sold in North America are used exclusively for commuting, school runs, and grocery trips. Despite this, buyers pay thousands extra for four wheel drive systems and rugged designs. A Honda CR V AWD costs about 1,500 dollars more than the front wheel drive version, yet most owners will never use the capability beyond a snowy driveway. For light off road travel, a Subaru Outback or even a compact hatchback with all wheel drive delivers everything most people realistically need.
Poor Fuel Economy
SUVs carry extra weight and have a taller, less aerodynamic shape. That translates directly into higher fuel consumption. A Toyota Camry four cylinder averages around 32 mpg combined, while a similarly priced Toyota RAV4 averages 27 mpg. Over 15,000 miles per year, that difference adds nearly 200 gallons of fuel, which at 4 dollars per gallon is over 800 dollars annually. For larger SUVs like the Ford Explorer, which often averages 22 mpg or less, the cost gap widens even further. Sedans and wagons remain more efficient without sacrificing comfort.
Higher Purchase Prices
SUVs almost always cost more than the cars they are based on. A Toyota Corolla starts at around 22,000 dollars, while the mechanically similar Toyota Corolla Cross SUV begins near 25,000 dollars. That is a 3,000 dollar premium for extra height and a bulkier body with similar engines and features. Over a six year loan, that equates to roughly 50 dollars more per month in payments. Buyers are essentially paying for image rather than tangible improvements.
Costlier Insurance
Insurance rates often climb when moving from a sedan to an SUV. Insurers cite higher repair costs, increased accident severity, and theft rates as factors. On average, owners pay 10 to 15 percent more annually to insure an SUV compared to a sedan of the same class. For example, insuring a Honda Accord might cost around 1,400 dollars per year, while a Honda CR V can climb to 1,600 or more. Over a decade of ownership, that is thousands of dollars in added expense.
Compromised Handling
SUVs are heavier and sit higher, which compromises handling and ride quality. Even sporty crossovers cannot match the balance of a sedan or hatchback. A Mazda CX 5, often praised for its sharp handling, still posts slower slalom speeds and longer braking distances than a Mazda3 hatchback, despite similar pricing. For drivers who spend most of their time on pavement, cars are more agile, safer in emergency maneuvers, and more rewarding to drive.
Limited Interior Flexibility
SUVs appear roomy, but the space is not always used efficiently. Sloping rooflines and raised floors often eat into cargo and passenger room. A Subaru Outback wagon offers 75.6 cubic feet of cargo space with the seats folded, while a Toyota RAV4 SUV offers 69.8. Third row SUVs like the Toyota Highlander cram seats into tight spaces that adults can barely use, whereas a minivan like the Honda Odyssey provides 158 cubic feet of total cargo room and comfortable seating for adults in all three rows. In practice, wagons and minivans outshine SUVs in practicality.
Expensive Tires and Maintenance
SUVs usually ride on larger wheels and tires, which are significantly more expensive to replace. A set of quality tires for a Honda CR V can cost around 700 dollars, while tires for a Honda Civic often run closer to 450. Larger brake components and suspension parts also wear faster under the SUV’s added weight. Over ten years, the maintenance premium of owning an SUV compared to a car can add thousands of dollars to the total cost of ownership.
Safety Misconceptions
Many assume SUVs are safer simply because they are bigger, but this is not always true. Their higher center of gravity makes them more prone to rollovers. While crash tests show good protection in frontal and side impacts, sedans often perform equally well thanks to advanced safety systems. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety has repeatedly shown that modern sedans like the Honda Accord or Toyota Camry score as highly as many SUVs in crash ratings, sometimes outperforming them.
Overkill for City Driving
Urban drivers flock to SUVs, but these vehicles are poorly suited for city life. Their larger size makes parking more difficult and navigating narrow streets more stressful. In places like New York or Toronto, compact cars such as the Toyota Corolla or Honda Fit slip into tight spaces with ease while using less fuel. The average SUV owner in the city rarely exploits the benefits of the size but deals with the daily hassle of maneuvering a bulky machine.
Inflated Status Symbol
SUVs have become fashion statements rather than tools. Automakers market them as adventurous and rugged, but most serve as little more than suburban commuters. A family buying a BMW X5 often ends up using it for the same school runs that a BMW 5 Series sedan could handle more comfortably and efficiently. The SUV has become a status symbol where buyers are willing to pay thousands more for perceived prestige, even if it adds no real advantage.
Alternatives Do the Job Better
The vehicles SUVs are meant to replace often perform better in their roles. A Honda Odyssey minivan carries more passengers and cargo, while a Subaru Outback wagon offers equal or better cargo space and superior fuel economy compared to similarly priced SUVs. For commuting, sedans like the Toyota Camry or Hyundai Sonata provide more comfort, better efficiency, and lower costs. The SUV ends up being a compromise that is less effective than specialized alternatives.
Environmental Impact
Because of their size and fuel consumption, SUVs produce more emissions than smaller vehicles. The Environmental Protection Agency has reported that the rise of SUVs has offset much of the progress made by electric vehicles and hybrids in reducing emissions. For example, an SUV like the Chevrolet Tahoe emits nearly 6.5 tons of CO2 annually, while a Toyota Corolla produces around 4.2 tons. For a driver who rarely uses the extra space or capability, that environmental cost is difficult to justify.
25 Facts About Car Loans That Most Drivers Don’t Realize
Car loans are one of the most common ways people fund car purchases. Like any other kind of loan, car loans can have certain features that can be regarded as an advantage or a disadvantage to the borrower. Understanding all essential facts about car loans and how they work to ensure that you get the best deal for your financial situation is essential. Here are 25 shocking facts about car loans that most drivers don’t realize:
25 Facts About Car Loans That Most Drivers Don’t Realize
